Revisiting the Proofs for the Existence of God: A Comparative ‎Study of Western and Islamic Perspectives

Articles in Press

Document Type : Original Article

Author

Faculty member at Research Institute for Islamic Culture and Thought

10.22081/jti.2023.67808.1048

Abstract

This study employs a descriptive-analytical method and a critical comparative approach to examine, critique, and compare the proofs for the existence of God in Western and Islamic philosophy. The introduction clarifies the meaning of proof and distinguishes it from faith and reasoning. It then outlines key concepts necessary for a deeper understanding of the proofs for God’s existence, including the role of Western and Islamic philosophers in shaping these arguments, the distinction between horizontal and vertical proofs in Western and Islamic traditions, and the empiricist and rationalist approaches to these arguments in both intellectual traditions. Following this foundation, the article systematically analyzes four categories of arguments for God's existence: ontological, cosmological, teleological (design), and moral arguments, as presented by Western thinkers. These arguments are then examined and critiqued based on the principles of Islamic philosophy. Throughout the discussion, the study highlights how misunderstandings or misinterpretations of key concepts and rational principles unique to Islamic philosophy—particularly in general and special metaphysics—have contributed to certain misapprehensions in the history of Western philosophy regarding proofs for God’s existence.

Keywords

References

  1. Abbaszadeh, M. (2019). The epistemological system of Suhrawardi's Illuminationist Philosophy (3rd ed.). Tehran: Organization for Research and Publishing of the Institute for Islamic Culture and Thought.
  2. Abbaszadeh, M. (2023). The epistemological system of Farabi (First ed.). Tehran: Organization for Research and Publishing of the Institute for Islamic Culture and Thought.
  3. Ayatollahy, H. (2010). The ontological or necessary being argument. In A. Rashad (Ed.), Sharīʿat-i khirad: a commemorative collection for Allama Mohammad-Taqi Jafari (2nd ed., pp. 441–453). Tehran: Organization for Research and Publishing of the Institute for Islamic Culture and Thought. [In Persian]
  4. Ayatollahy, H. (n.d.). Evaluation of the proofs for the existence of God in Western and Islamic thought. Retrieved from https://www.academia.edu. [In Persian]
  5. Ayatollahy, H., & Shorvarzi, H. (2014). The Fine-Tuning Argument: Analyzing the Views of Sober and Its Defenders. Journal of Philosophical Inquiry in Religion, 3(2), 73–88. [In Persian]
  6. Descartes, R. (1986). Meditations on first philosophy (J. Cottingham, Trans. & Ed.). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  7. Geisler, N. (2005). Philosophy of Religion (H. Ayatollahy, Trans.). Tehran: Hekmat Publishing.
  8. Haeri Yazdi, M. (2005). Investigations into theoretical reason (4th ed.). Tehran: Iranian Research Institute of Philosophy. [In Persian]
  9. Hume, D. (2013). Dialogues concerning natural religion. New York: Start Publishing LLC.
  10. Ibn Sīnā. (1983). Al-Shifāʾ (Theology) (Saeed Zayed, Ed.). Qom: Ayatollah Marashi Library. [In Arabic]
  11. Ibn Sīnā. (1996). Al-Ishārāt wa-l-tanbīhāt (First ed.). Qom: Al-Balagha Publishing. [In Arabic]
  12. Javadi Amoli, A. (1995). Explanation of the proofs for God's existence (First ed.). Qom: Esra Publishing Center. [In Persian]
  13. Kant, I. (1998). Critique of pure reason (P. Guyer & A. W. Wood, Trans. & Eds.). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  14. Khansari, M. (1992). Formal logic (Vol. 2, 14th ed.). Tehran: Agah Publishing. [In Persian]
  15. Motahari, M. (2007). Footnotes on "The Principles of Philosophy and the Method of Realism" (Vol. 5, 11th ed.). Tehran: Sadra Publishing.
  16. Mullā Ṣadrā (Ṣadr al-Dīn Muḥammad ibn Ibrāhīm Shīrāzī). (1981). Al-Ḥikmat al-Mutaʿāliya fī al-asfār al-ʿaqliyyat al-arbaʿa (Vol. 1, 3rd ed.). Beirut: Dar Ihya al-Turath.
  17. Mullā Ṣadrā (Ṣadr al-Dīn Muḥammad ibn Ibrāhīm Shīrāzī). (1981). Al-Shawāhid al-rubūbiyya fī al-manāhij al-sulūkiyya (2nd ed.). Mashhad: University Publishing Center.
  18. Naghibzadeh, M. A. (1995). Kant’s philosophy: awakening from dogmatic slumber. Tehran: Agah Publishing.
  19. Peterson, M., Hasker, W., Reichenbach, B., & Basinger, D. (1997). Reason and Religious Belief: An Introduction to the Philosophy of Religion (A. Naraghi & E. Soltani, Trans.). Tehran: Tarh-e Now Publishing. [In Persian]
  20. Russell, B. (2009). The basic writings of Bertrand Russell. London: Routledge.
  21. Ṭabāṭabāʾī, S. M. H. (2003). Nihāyat al-ḥikma (A. Zarei Sabzevari, Ed., 18th ed.). Qom: Islamic Publishing Office.
Theosophia Islamica

Articles in Press, Corrected Proof
Available Online from 01 March 2023

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics