Research Article On Motahhari's Theodicy of Hell

Document Type : Original Article

Author

Department of Islamic philosophy, Faculty of theology, Ferdowsi university, Mashhad, Iran.

Abstract

One of the main problems for the doctrine of the traditional view of hell is Proportionality objection. It claims that eternal punishments for finite crimes of human beings cause undue harm and therefore are incompatible with divine justice. The proportionality principle states that the degree of punishment that a person justly merits must be proportionate to the level of his wrongdoing. One of the common ways to respond to this objection is rejecting the retributive nature of hell. Morteza Motahhari denied retributivism by distinguishing between the criminal system of the world and hereafter. He believed punishments in hell are identical to human deeds and they are nothing more than spiritual aspect of them. Regarding this view which is called 'Self-imposed punishments', God is not the punisher of the sinners, and the residents of hell suffer from their sinful actions. This paper begins with examining Motahhari's metaphysical theory of punishment as a theodicy of hell. Then I will discuss a modal argument against his theory. I shall argue there is not a necessary correlation between crimes and punishments. My conclusion is that Motahhari's theodicy would be undermined God's moral perfection either therefore it does not get God off the moral hook.

Keywords

References

Clark,K. J. (2001). God is Great,GodisGood:Medieval Conceptions of Divine Goodness and the Problem of Hell. Religious Studies,37(1), pp. 15-31. doi:10.1017/S0034412500005461
Kershnar, S. (2005). The Injustice of Hell. International Journal for Philosophy of Religion, 58(2), pp. 103-123.
Kvanvig, J. L. (1993). The Problem of Hell. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Lewis, D. (2007). Divine Evil. In Philosophers without Gods: Meditations on Atheism and the Secular Life (L.M. Antony, Ed.). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Motahhari, M. (2004). Divine Justice (S.H.Abidi, M.Alidina& Sh. AliMirza, Trans.).Qom: International Institute forIslamic Studies.
Motahhari, M. (1985). Eternal Life (Life After Death) (M. Sohrabi & Z. Kasraian, Trans). Tehran: Islamic Propagation Organization.
Plantinga, A. (1974). The Nature of Necessity. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Seymour, C. (2000). A Theodicy of Hell. Netherlands: Springer.
Theosophia Islamica
Volume 1, Issue 1 - Serial Number 1
January 2021
Pages 127-139

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics